Flying Tigers: Trade Deadline Explosion


In developments that can only be described as shocking, the Tigers executed a last-minute trade for pitcher David Price, sending Austin Jackson to Seattle and Drew Smyly to Tampa. (Seattle also sent Nick Franklin to Tampa.) The trade was finalized while Detroit was in the middle of a game both Smyly and Jackson had started, and Jackson had to be pulled off the field when the deal was done. 

Whatever I wrote about the Soria trade a week ago in terms of price is irrelevant today. I don’t want to overstate what Jackson has meant and what Smyly has and could have meant to the Tigers, but suffice it to say: they are not mere prospects. They are two regular, MLB-level starters.

Price, of course, is a top-level starting pitcher, and (like Smyly) a lefty to boot. The Vanderbilt graduate is a Cy Young winner and easily was the best starting pitcher even potentially available at the trade deadline. His one weakness may be his susceptibility to home runs, but he makes up for that with superior abilities in every other area.

I wrote just a few hours ago that the Tigers should consider trading for offense, while conceding that more bullpen help probably made more sense. Price addresses neither of these concerns. The Price acquisition begins to make some sense, though, when seen as a reaction to the failed offseason efforts to retain Max Scherzer. Max is very likely to be wearing a different uniform next season, and Price is his replacement.

Because of the way the series are structured, fewer starting pitchers are needed in the playoffs. One of the nice things about Smyly was that, even as the team was developing him as a starter, he could easily transition back into a shutdown southpaw out of the bullpen in the postseason. Soria ought to address that somewhat, although all he’s done in two outings with his new team is have the two worst outings of his career. Soria’s a righty, though, and the only two left-handed members of the Tiger bullpen remain the objectively bad Phil Coke and Ian Krol.

Anyway, here’s a look at the new Detroit starting rotation:

  1. Max Scherzer
  2. David Price
  3. Anibal Sanchez
  4. Rick Porcello
  5. Justin Verlander

Whatever the above frittering amounts to, the starting rotation obviously is going to be just fine. The team now has a big hole in center field, though, and in critical postseason games played in spacious Comerica Park and the Oakland Coliseum, that could spell trouble.

The trade for Price makes sense, to the extent it does, for next year. A trade for an outfield bat or a lefty reliever would have made sense for this year.

Farewell to Jackson and Smyly.


Where are the Bats? – 7/31
Detroit finds relief, but at what price? – 7/24
Closing Time? – 6/4
Closing the Book on 2013
– 6/2
Victor Martinez, Professional Hitter
 – 5/7
Actually Mad Max
 – 4/29
Waiting for Takeoff – 4/28

Farewell, sweet Prince


6 thoughts on “Flying Tigers: Trade Deadline Explosion

  1. In the interest of providing balanced coverage, below are the results of a poll from I find the overwhelming support of the trade there surprising not because it places me in the minority, but because I always thought of the fans there as cynical and neurotic worrywarts, and the Price trade doesn’t strike me as the sort of move that would be so warmly welcomed by that group.

    • And now that the trade-deadline dust has begun to settle, the smart numbers are coming in, and the results are only slightly mixed. Baseball Prospectus’ PECOTA machine determined that the Tigers actually are less likely (87.3% vs. 86.7%) to make the playoffs, although it also spit out an increase in World Series odds (12.1% vs. 12.6%). Meanwhile, FanGraphs has Detroit as the biggest gainer (+2.0%) in championship odds:

      And here is why the Tigers acquired David Price. They already were extremely likely to make the playoffs, but putting Price on their roster made them — according to our forecasts — the best team in baseball going forward. A two percent swing might not sound like much, but we’re talking about a two percent improvement in achieving the team’s ultimate goal. Yesterday was a good day for the Tigers.

  2. Pingback: Flying Tigers: How the David Price trade could help the bullpen | ALDLAND

  3. Pingback: Big Leagued: Durham Bulls comeback fails, fall to Charlotte 6-5 | ALDLAND

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s